Guest Stars Jason Alan Carvell as Jimmy Boyd Derek Webster as FBI Agent Raymond Isler Tonya Pinkins as Julie Jeff Fahey as Charlie Conroy Tobias Jelinek as Will Kirby Coby Ryan McLaughlin as Ken Crawford Craig "muMs" Grant as Larry Co Starring Kelly Murtagh as Anne Crawford Samuel Ray Gates as Interim Special Agent in Charge Nathan Kendall Kraig Dane as Pierce Evans