Guest Stars Aparna Brielle as Sarika Sarkar Nick Peine as Marcus Kasperak Meagen Fay as Sister Frances Nancy Friedrich as Sister Monica Co Starring Allisyn Ashley Arm as Heather Willmore Eddie Leavy as Anthony Lewis Jacob Houston as Victor Kozlowski Sari Arambulo as Grace Spence Moore II as Dan Decker Marisa Baram as Marissa Jacob Timothy Manown as Caleb Baker Miguel Chavez as Eduardo Dan Gilvary as Priest
