Guest Stars Erica Gimpel as Trisha Adam Goldberg as Simon Hayes Michel Gill as Wilson Christopher Redman as John Dove Cara Buono as Karen Jeffrey Pierce as Richard Shamika Cotton as Jen Co Starring Robert McKay as Lester Tracee Beazer as Diana Arica Himmel as Lindsay Ava McCoy as Young Parishioner Roger Hall as Ryan/Mailroom Clerk Kim Park as Teacher Tom Ashton as St. Michaels Male Parishioner