Guest Stars Ethan Maher as Sami Ben Ahlers as Liam Aimee Carrero as Sofia Lopez Pej Vahdat as Hamid Mary Beth Peil as Gwendolena Kurt Yaeger as Joe Nadine Nicole as Amy Bowman Amber Skye Noyes as Alanna Will Meyers as Jagger Tucker Anna George as Shirin Ismail Bashey as Abbas Azmoun Co Starring Neil Hoover as Kyle Supriya Ganesh as Hipster Girl Tricia Paoluccio as Wife Connie Shi as Bartender Masha King as Karaoke MC Adam Shippey as Wall Street Bro Satomi Blair as New Mom Allison McKay as Gladys Sean McIntyre as Older Man Jordan Sobel as Husband Kate Yeager as Broadway Belter Roya Shanks as Arty Wife