Guest Stars Lou Ferrigno Jr. as Tommy Kinard Lauren Stamile as Ellie Laura Allen as Marcy Nash Anthony Turpel as Freddie Gino Anthony Pesi as Sal Deluca Eddie McClintock as Victor Andy Umberger as Deputy Chief Phil Evans Nick Searcy as Father Jameson Co Starring London Cheshire as Robert Nash Jr Noelle E Parker as Brook Nash Chasty Ballesteros as Julie Joshua Dov as Ted Shaw Jones as Minnesota Priest Daniel Edward Mora as Oscar Cassandra Nuss as Amy Sean Nateghi as EMT-Minnesota Brian Molina as Young EMT David Carrera as Attendee Chandra Thomas as Waitress Zac Badasci as Twenty Something