Guest Stars Dalton Harrod as Craig Harrison Jamie Neumann as Tiffany Jones Darby Camp as Haley Smith Asher Miles Fallica as Daniel Moore Chris McKinney as Sheriff Joe Bly Paulina Singer as Willa Brewster Rarmian Newton as Drew Karen Pittman as Angela Brewster Michael Maize as Peter Ives Co Starring Misha Osherovich as Simon Nicole Ehinger as Brenda Oscar Wahlberg as Matty Sonnie Brown as Mary Simonson Josephine Elwood as Molly Jackson Mercado as Brian Johnson Megan McQuillan as Karen Moore Cody Caffrey as Pete David Charland as Dishwasher
