Guest Stars Chance Kelly as Ed Cutler Ambyr Childers as Susan Atkins David Meunier as Roy Kovic Jodi Harris as Opal Chris Sheffield as Walt Hodiak Gaius Charles as Bunchy Carter Abby Miller as Mary Brunner Lobo Sebastian as Guapo Beau Mirchoff as Rick Zondervan James Martinez as Ruben Salazar Richard Libertini as Saul Hodiak Yetide Badaki as Rita Carter Dendrie Taylor as Kathleen Maddox Hampton Fluker as Theo Pinkner Andrew Borba as Rich Sanburg Co Starring Michael Patrick McGill as Jim Whalen Gabriel Chavarria as Juan Barry W. Levy as Mr. Zondervan Elizabeth Penn Payne as Female Uniform Uncredited Brian Poth as Chris Christopher Arminio as Straight Satan Biker Carl Conti as Detective