Guest Stars Noelle Renée Bercy as Evita Angela Davis as Aunt Chantelle Dilshad Vadsaria as Avandalia "Lia" Dewan Brooklyn McLinn as Andre Deschaine Lane Miller as Fuchs Jaime Zevallos as Father Francis Delgado Devyn Ariel Tyler as Ballet Instructor Justin Sams as Baron Samedi Co Starring Brian Matney as Veteran Detective Jason Bayle as SUV Guy Taron Germany as Officer Newman