Guest Stars Taissa Farmiga as Annie Miller Luke Kirby as Dylan Ike Barinholtz as Mike Percy Hynes White as Cole Rhea Seehorn as Martha Peter Kelamis as Phil Smith Co Starring Steph Song as Olivia James Ralph as Bartender Jill Morrison as Robyn Paul Piaskowski as Zeke the Geek Adam Beauchesne as Newscaster Duncan Minett as Larry Leif Havdale as Stunt Civilian #2 Jeremiah Oh as Guy #5 Jeff Gladstone as Perry Sullivan Sarah Ziolkowski as Medical Technician #2 Anthony Scardera as Gas Station Guy Agape Mngomezulu as Steve Marion Landers as Scientist Alex Pepin as National Guardsman Cooper Bibaud as Zealot Man