Guest Stars June Diane Raphael as Julie Gristlewhite Abigail Spencer as Annie Janet Varney as Carly Natasha Leggero as Haley Beth Dover as Lexie Noureen DeWulf as Titi Malin Akerman as Willow Deanna Russo as Tamara G Morgan Vukovic as Vivian Helen Slayton-Hughes as Agnes Kristen Bell as Mandy