Guest Stars Evelyn Keyes as Sister Emily Ed Nelson as Mayor Albert Simpson Robert Prosky as Bishop Patrick Shea Mark Keyloun as Mike Phelps Jane Powell as Rev. Mother Claire Scott Paulin as Dr. Marshall Cindy Fisher as Nancy Bates Clu Gulager as Ray Carter Eileen Brennan as Marian Simpson Audrey Totter as Sister Paul Co Starring Carol Swarbrick as Sister Margaret-Marie Sherri Stoner as Sarah Martino Fay DeWitt as Sister Mary-Margaret Wendy Brainard as Amy M'el Dowd as Sister Margaret-Mary Caroline Gilshian as Sister Anne
