Guest Stars Kelly Collins Lintz as Tracy Connelly Linsey Godfrey as Caitlin Blum Martha Plimpton as Mr. Big / Dr. Morris Co Starring Caroline Kent as Emily Connelly Stephen Michael Ayers as Paul Blum Jack Landry as Jared Victoria Staley as Heather Connelly Dikran Tulaine as The Gardener Brett Pryor as Mr. Joiner Sylvia Jefferies as Mrs. Joiner Gil Johnson as Sheriff Mike Flippo as Hunter Foster Walker as Librarian Jimmy Hager as Townsperson #1 Tom Turbiville as Trawler Captain Rhoda Griffis as Annie Boertz Rick Warner as Interviewer Alan Britt as Townsperson #2 Jody Quaranta as Aquarium Worker Don Henderson Baker as Dave Wolff Nick Battiste as Ed Blagman Kerry Maher as Friend
