Guest Stars Alanna Ubach as Suze Austin Abrams as Ethan Paula Marshall as Marsha Zak Steiner as Aaron Keean Johnson as Daniel Lukas Gage as Tyler Cranston Johnson as Frederick McKay Co Starring Tyler Timmons as Troy Jason Medwin as Pee Wee Ref Aileen Burdock as Detective Riley Hannah Nordberg as Emma Wilzette Borno as Receptionist Zakai Biagas-Bey as 11-Year-Old McKay Yohance Biagas-Bey as 11-Year-Old McKay Jim Garrity as Tim (Manager) Michael Petrone as Pee Wee Coach Biff Miller as Frat Bro Julia Nye as Drunk Frat Girl David Meza as Jock Dino Lorenzo Scordia as Cornerback Michael Franklin as Police Officer Percy Smith as Pay Pig Nick King as Michael (Maître d') Dominic Goodman as Frat Bro Jeff Sanders as Offensive Coordinator Rich Grosso as Pay Pig Thomas F. Evans as Pay Pig Stuart McLean as Pay Pig