Guest Stars B.K. Cannon as Kris Dylan McDermott as Theo Klein January Jones as Lizbeth Klein Eric Nenninger as Detective Co Starring Koby Kumi-Diaka as Pierre Toussaint Sky Soleil as Officer McKay Carrie Gibson as Waitress Jordan Preston as Polygraph Cop Zehra Fazal as Reporter Theo Wilson as Anchor Steve Brock Michael James Bell as Asshole Guest Sammy Busby as Police Chief Louise Bennett as Nancy Grace-Type