Guest Stars Colby Minifie as Ashley Barrett Jordana Lajoie as Cherie Nicola Correia-Damude as Elena Ann Cusack as Donna January Jess Salgueiro as Robin Ward Shaun Benson as Ezekiel Brittany Allen as Charlotte / Popclaw Billy Zane as Himself Brit Morgan as Rachel Saunders Co Starring Nneka Elliott as Female News Anchor Roger Petersen as Male News Anchor Billy Turnbull as Trevor Hallea Jones as Older Girl Jim Annan as Pastor John Joel Rinzler as Groundskeeper Shanice Johnson as Curious Girl Jenny Brizard as Hair Stylist Evangelia Kambites as Supe Gospel Singer Thomas Hauff as Pastor Aiden Altow as Shy Boy Nicole Maroon as Emotional Donor Tiana Leonty as Believe Attendee John Williams as Older Donor