Guest Stars Alicia Coppola as Sheila Mosconi Leo Howard as Tommy Harte Katie Finneran as Naomi Harte Lio Tipton as Mary Philip Anthony-Rodriguez as Hector Scott Porter as Ralph Abbie Cobb as Abby Ron Roggé as Detective Hanel Adam Shapiro as Andrew Co Starring Marcel Nahapetian as Benny Helen Highfield as Gloria Frank Gallegos as Levi Claudia Choi as Detective Mindee Jack Armstrong as Cole Betsy Baker as Jimmy's Mom T.J. Hoban as Paulo Jason Boegh as Walter Michael A. Shepperd as Ken Grinnell Morris as Chip Catherine Curry as Elsie Rain Valdez as Chiffon Esteban Diaz-Estorga as Young Tommy