Guest Stars Beth Grant as Cat Lady Matthew Gray Gubler as Wes Goran Višnjić as Colin Brooks Derek Theler as Ryan Ben Lawson as Oliver Jeff Meacham as Rodney Co Starring Melanie Reif as Paramedic #1 Troy Ian Hall as Aiden Sterling Jones as Paul Cathryn Mudon as Gynecologist Sean Jenkins as Neil Eric Focused Wright as Waiter Cole Shoemaker as Greg Marnina Schon as Instinct #1 Shaina Vorspan as Instinct #2 Fayna Sanchez as Paramedic #2 Jason Daniel Chacon as Wayne