Guest Stars James Wolk as Joe Keene Cheyenne Jackson as Hooded Justice (American Hero Story) Paula Malcomson as Renee Steve Coulter as Simmons Co Starring Coley Campany as Moderator Austin Freeman as Knot Top Karen Beyer as Well Dressed Woman Michael Rubino as Police Officer Cabot Basden as Knot Top Julia Vasi as Roxy Jason Turner as Receptionist Jesse Mattson as ED Support Group Tiger Dawn as ED Support Group Holly Stevenson as Older Woman Ryan Hope Travis as Jerry Ariel Milner as Child David Watts as Outdoorsy Man Jimi Kocina as Rorschach Tech Eileen Grubba as Cynthia Tillman Denise Hillis as ED Support Group Tim Peek as Elder Debra Nelson as ED Support Group Chris Whitley as Captain Metropolis Victor Turner as Receptionist Omer Mughal as Moderator Philip Labes as Young Wade Tillman Uncredited Michael Imperioli as Actor in NY Commercial