Guest Stars Katherine LaNasa as Noa Havilland Tami Roman as Lillian Scoville Billy Miller as Alex Dunn Annabella Sciorra as Erin Buhrman Brett Cullen as Owen Cave Nicholas Bishop as Chuck Buhrman Molly Hagan as Susan Carver Colby French as Detective Hunter Stephanie Maura Sanchez as Nina Cedillo James Hornbeck as TBD Co Starring Rico E. Anderson as Herbie Hunter Doohan as Teenage Warren Mayson Weinstein as Young Josie Stella Weinstein as Young Lanie Rebecca Huey as Teenage Josie Caroline Huey as Teenage Lanie Everleigh McDonell as Ella Dunn Barry Livingston as Harris McQuaid Janora McDuffie as Processing Clerk Harris Christopher Wolfe as Male Newscaster Jance Enslin as Jeremy / Grandson Kate Connor as A.D.A. Norah Bowdoin Jeff Elam as Prison Director Scott Adalgiza Chermont as Nurse Kimberly Ursula Burton as Professor Simmons Wayne Bastrup as Dead Eyed Clerk Anastasia Barnes as Female Deputy Lyn Alicia Henderson as Catholic Priest Brooke Thomas as Female Newscaster Starr Gilliard as Sister Claire Andy Hoff as A.D.A. Gary Lawrence Tom Sean Foley as Elderly Woman's Son Tacey Adams as Elderly Woman's Sister