Guest Stars Boris McGiver as Monsignor Matthew Korecki Kristen Connolly as Detective Mira Byrd Clark Johnson as Father Amara Noah Robbins as Sebastian Lewin Dan Bittner as Dwight Farrell Annaleigh Ashford as Bridget Farrell Evelyn Giovine as Linda Anthony Alessandro as Mateo Rocco Sisto as Silvio Pedro Carmo as Vincent Co Starring Stephen Cefalu, Jr. as Jonathan Conor Proft as Incel 1 Janine DiVita as Roberta Moretti Matt Walker as Incel 2
