Guest Stars Carolyn McCormick as Judge Marion Stadler Samantha Mathis as Avery Kress Demosthenes Chrysan as Amir Elmasry Montego Glover as Astrid Montego Griffin Santopietro as James Donovan Co Starring Ashley Brooke as Makayla David Oliver as Juror #12 Michael McFadden as Paul Martin Briana Swann Christie as Juror #3 Patricia Mauceri as Fatima Elmasry Denim Roberson as Henry Alyssa Keegan as Kim Donovan Debra Wassum as Juror #8
