Guest Stars Jermel Nakia as Young William Joy Brunson as Shauna Blake Stadnik as Jack Damon Michael Angarano as Nicky Pearson Auden Thornton as Lucy Co Starring Joaquin Obradors as Young Jack Donnie Masihi as Young Nicky Makenzie Lee-Foster as Young Déjà AJ Carr as Terrance Charles Kim as New Owner Kevin Symons as Officer Duffy Todd Aaron Brotze as Waiter Kim D'Armond as Cashier Grace Shen as Waitress Sergio Harford as Not-William Bruce Merkle as Worker Cara Jade Myers as Officer Jorgensen
