Guest Stars Jack Fisher as Phineas Louise Barnes as Sarah Sonya Leslie as Nancy Paul Norwood as Jesse Gilyard Rick Overton as Elmer Barlow Tyler Francavilla as Dustin Vanderschmitt Serafina Polite as Emma Co Starring Briana Cuoco as Rosalind Reatha Grey as Marion Christopher Bencomo as Navy Petty Officer First Class Ian Rojas Carter Mitchell as Virgil