Guest Stars Molly Griggs as Eve Blanchard Charlayne Woodard as Dr. Gabrielle Le Deux Anna Eilinsfeld as The Girl in the Box James Cusati-Moyer as Nico Stavros Kristen Connolly as Beth Saverstein Carra Patterson as Tally Mara Davi as Simone Jeremy Shamos as David Saverstein Jennifer Lim as Stacy Co Starring Michael Sharits as Caleb Hardy