Guest Stars Greta Lee as Celeste Jack O'Connell as Benjy Everett Co Starring Chick Roberts as Even Older Familiar Rakhee Morzaria as Karen Ben Sanders as Brad Tricia Black as Young Familiar Erica Anderson as Kimya Adam Christie as Young Comic Joy Castro as Drunk Loud Woman Tig Fong as Jogger Amish Patel as Crowd #2 Derek Barnes as Emcee Kayla Dumont as Crowd #1 Ava Arrindell as Teen Girl Vampire #1 Lilly Bartlam as Houston Abby Stretch as Teen Girl Vampire #3
