Special Guest Stars Alexandra Breckenridge as Sophie Guest Stars Caitlin Thompson as Madison Amanda Leighton as Teenage Sophie M. Night Shyamalan as Himself Jennifer Westfeldt as Claire Co Starring Kaz Womack as Kevin (6 y/o) Sophia Coto as Sophie (12 y/o) Ruben Vernier as PA Sharon Blynn as Script Supervisor Adam Simpson as Usher Michael Govier as Lyft Driver Whit Washing as Pastor