Guest Stars Grace Victoria Cox as Melanie Cross Aisha Hinds as Carolyn Hill Dale Raoul as Andrea Grinnell Gavin Goodell as Henchman #2 Jimmie Lee Sessoms as Henchman #3 Ben P. Jensen as Henchman #1 Co Starring Eugene H. Russell IV as Townsperson Reide Hale as Young Lyle Hannah Black as Young Pauline Michael Tourek as Wendell Dwayne Boyd as Greg Austin James Parker as Young Sam Tia Hendricks as Female Heckler Samantha Worthen as Scared Miller