Special Guest Stars Jeannie Berlin as Ruth Heidelbaum Judd Hirsch as Simon Wiesenthal Guest Stars Jonno Davies as Tobias Julissa Bermudez as Maria De La Ruiz Megan Channell as Katarina Löw Annie Hägg as Young Ruth Zack Schor as Young Meyer James Le Gros as Chief Harry Grimsby Christian Oliver as Wilhelm Zuchs Ronald Guttman as Moritz Ehrlich Caleb Emery as Arthur "Bootyhole" McGuigan Celia Weston as Dottie Josh Mostel as Rabbi Steckler Andre Ware as Lou Morris Myra Lucretia Taylor as Viola Morris Francesca Faridany as Patricia Collins Todd Alan Crain as Bill Badger Victor Slezak as Wernher Von Braun Co Starring Phoenix Noelle Reece as Malika Joshua Satine as Aaron Markowitz Hannah Reid Rubinek as Amy Markowitz Steven Kaplan as Ben Rosenfeld Art McFarland as Priest Mark Rowe as FBI Agent #3 Roosevelt Davis as Haitian American Father Delance Minefee as FBI Agent #1 Perry Strong as FBI Agent #2 Milan Marsh as Rachelle Lizzy Plimpton as Joyce Remington Jay Perregaux as Blonde Young Man Jack O'Connell as Mel Logan Sutherland as Emerson Jay Rivera as Police Officer Maldonado Candice Jean-Jacques as Haitian American Mother
