Guest Stars Ato Essandoh as Gaddis Jane Alexander as Klara Co Starring Robert Nahum as Logan the Bartender Christin Park as Stacey Stefanie Estes as Sarah the Teacher Sierra Alexis as Zoe Carter Heintz as Nate Kassianni Austin as Molly (30-50) Shane Carruth as Cole (50s) Jamie Parcells as Cole (30s / 40s) James Janssens as Cole (80s) Dylan Bodner as Cole (20s) Lynn G. LePage as Molly (80s) Kaelan McLaren as Alex (10) Fay Kelman as Olivia (40) Trevor Russell as Nate (40) Jodi Lynn Thomas as Klara (20s)