Guest Stars Joanne Miller as Louise Reid Dennis Andres as Conner Star Slade as Cheryl Battiste Gail Maurice as Annabel Draper Drew Nelson as Victor Deer Catherine Thomas as Clerk / Susan Ellyn Jade as Morningstar Cope Colby Conrad as Dillon Lovett Hardee T. Lineham as Judge Reynolds Andrew Chandler as Johnathan Castleman John Watson as Sheriff Ted Lita Llewellyn as Kathryn (Mediator) Shaun Clarke as Ronan Hawley Bailey Maughan as Brent Larson Kimberley Bernard as Ms. Juanita Stevens