Guest Stars Kimiko Glenn as Lily Siobhan Williams as Jo Emily Alyn Lind as Jolene Drygulski Odiseas Georgiadis as Terrence Avery Konrad as Roan Harper Michael Kopsa as William Kingston Madison Mason as Reverend Harper Co Starring Hayven Oladapo as Young Elsie Janet Glassford as Foster Parent Mike Wasko as Foster Parent Benjamin Goas as Church Boy #1 Mila Morgan as Church Girl Mya Lowe as Laughing Girl Calix Fraser as Church Boy #2 David H. Lyle as Man With Scar #4 Lauren Acala as TBA Laura Clarke as Church Woman #2 Jared Arthur as Man with Scar #1 Victoria Souter as Church Woman #1 Justin Lacey as Man with Scar #2 Duncan Alexander Jones as Man With Scar #5 Emily Matchette as TBA Rob Jacobsen as Man With Scar #3