Guest Stars Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Zach Gilford as Greg Rob Heaps as Dr. Josh Cohen Andrew McCarthy as James Fitzpatrick Rodney To as Agent Henry Dave Theune as Eric Ione Skye as Gayle Meyer Damien Leake as Pastor Collins Madeline Zima as Lila Dan Aid as Troy Co Starring Danny Boyd Jr. as Harry Hill Carlos Aviles as Mick Shantell Yasmine Abeydeera as Salon Manager Ronit Aranoff as Young Mother