Guest Stars Henry Simmons as Isaac Wright Jordan Belfi as Neal Donovan Joan McMurtrey as Carla Sussman Michael Cavanaugh as Judge Newman Alison Martin as Judge Rita Bardos Erinn Hayes as Ellie Davis Sterling K. Brown as Quenton North Jennifer O'Dell as Sonja Crawford Julian Morris as Dylan Crawford Nicholas Braun as Craig Phillip Rhys as Philip Singh Nicholas Guest as William Prosk Christopher Foley as Teammate Co Starring Patrick Robert Smith as Sheriff Paul Keeley as Sonja's Lawyer Christian Svensson as Detective Greg Allan Martin as Brandon Crawford Mitch Longley as Mickey Strong