Guest Stars Lena Georgas as Janet Ravis Holley Fain as Evelyn Crowley Cliff Chamberlain as Rich Crowley Joelle Carter as Yvonne Newsome Michael Rispoli as Betty's Father Tiera Skovbye as Young Betty Chris Mason as Young Dan Doug Savant as Martin Newsome Spencer Garrett as Judge Spiller Missy Yager as Betty's Mother Albie Selznick as Doctor Co Starring Jesse Mackey as Detective Sheehan Scarlett Abinante as Young Tracy Beth Fraser as Law Wife #1 James Austin Kerr as Med Student #1 Alan Brooks as Father Groneman Riley Baron as Med Student #2 Melanie Hawkins as Law Wife #2 Emma Kennedy as Kate Dakota Somervill as Pre-Teen Betty