Guest Stars Georgina Reilly as Piper Michael Rady as Kurt Malick Grant Bowler as Gideon Hamilton Paul Ben-Victor as Contractor Co Starring Madelyn Sher as Amy Brian Tester as Mark Logan Samuel Gomez as Marlow St. John Andres A. Ramos as Carl Webber Jessica Maria Rodriguez as Marcia Pearl Brandhyze Stanley as Molly Fisher Tracee Beazer as Principal Howe Brendan Clack as Inspector Cecille Colón as Anna Cristina Soler as Gideon's Assistant