Guest Stars Jeffery Self as Marc Christine Taylor as Gail Ron Livingston as Keith Jay Duplass as Elijah Co Starring Phoebe Tyers as April Jacqueline Guillen as Reporter #1 Natalie Leer Walker as Gloria Lisa Haas as Meg Shunori Ramanathan as Steph Madison Elizabeth Lagares as Kaitlin Kaipo Schwab as Cop #3 Amanda Bruton as Cop #4 Ed Herbstman as Passenger Tim Nicolai as Reporter #2 Ed Incle as Mug Shot Photographer Austin Durant as Interrogator Buzz Roddy as Angry Man Hallie Haas as Mel Benina Robert Montano as Cop #2 Gil Ozeri as Cop #1