Guest Stars Tisha Campbell voices Tawny Young Andy Daly voices Two-Face / Dent Sanaa Lathan voices Catwoman Lake Bell voices Cheryl Mary Holland voices Tabitha Alan Tudyk voices Condiment King Jim Rash voices The Mayor Mary Holland voices Jennifer Christopher Meloni voices Guard Jim Rash voices Tad Andy Daly voices Mr. Covington Jonah Platt voices Singing Clayface