Guest Stars Sam McCarthy as Sam "Sammy" Barber Jr. Kate Vernon as Lily Partridge Glynnis O'Connor as Holly Sean Grandillo as Anders Crane Greg Bryk as Cardellini Rita Volk as Polina Lara Jean Chorostecki as Sarah Crane Noam Jenkins as Lior Co Starring Jaeda Owens as Maggie Piper McKale Thompson as Jimmy Piper Shawn Campbell as Tom Miller Michael Ripley as Chauffeur Joyce Rivera as Mae's Maid