Guest Stars Eric Lange as Detective Gene Holcomb Diarra Kilpatrick as Clara Drake Gayle Rankin as Emily Dodson Molly Ephraim as Hazel Prystock Andrew Howard as Detective Joe Ennis Robert Patrick as Herman Baggerly Lili Taylor as Birdy McKeegan Stephen Root as Maynard Barnes David Wilson Barnes as Elder Brown Veronica Falcón as Lupe Gibbs Taylor Nichols as Elder Eric Q. Seidel Nate Corddry as Matthew Dodson Matt Frewer as Judge Frederick Wright Jefferson Mays as Virgil Sheets Aaron Stanford as George Gannon Charles Baker as Stanislaw Nowak Matt Lasky as Marcin Sarecki Todd Weeks as Jim Hicks Todd Giebenhain as Terrence Smith Stephanie Hodge as Betty George Gerdes as Polish Old Timer Co Starring Karl Makinen as Commander Joe Morton Forte Rodriguez as Bailiff Bobby Reed as Juror Kevin Garbee as Juror Foreman Jason Boegh as Reporter at LAPD Alison White as Jail Matron Barbara Fry Jorge Borrelli as Fernando Molina Dahlya Glick as Acolyte Marcus Bailey as Cabbie Josh Allen Castillo as Mexican Painter Pamela Mitchell as Elaine Ennis Henry LeBlanc as Reformed Radiant Kevin Fabian as Commercial Clerk