Guest Stars Lena Georgas as Janet Ravis Holley Fain as Evelyn Crowley Missi Pyle as Karen Kintner Lily Donoghue as Tracy Broderick Anna Jacoby-Heron as Jenny Broderick Emily Bergl as Marie Stewart Cliff Chamberlain as Rich Crowley Miles Emmons as Anthony Broderick Cameron Crovetti as Ryan Broderick Joelle Carter as Yvonne Newsome Sprague Grayden as H.A.L.T. Member Michael Rispoli as Betty's Father Ron Perkins as Judge Edgar Russell Steven Culp as Baxter David Rees Snell as Therapist Audrey Moore as Celeste Anstead Romi Dias as Rosa Graham Sibley as Matthew Carpenter Co Starring Shanna Strong as Nancy Olivia Applegate as Allison Summer Sveinson as Courtney Catherine Carlen as Celia Justin Wade as Gary Shawn Harry Zinn as Criminal Court Judge Kristen O'Meara as Mrs. Mayer Josh Covitt as Mr. Norris