Guest Stars Andrew M. Duff as Ted Sakina Jaffrey as Vilina Nadia Mohebban as Ananya Ned Eisenberg as Al Sam Lazarus as Phil Mark Blane as Zack June Squibb as Mrs. Finch Tracy Wilder as Nurse Wanda Rita Gardner as Mrs. Joyce Mantone Barbara Singer as Sylvia Kevin Hagan as Mr. Sal Mantone Sohina Sidhu as Shivani Emma Hong as Samantha Katrina Lenk as Mary Jason Veasey as Marcus Ysabel Seeratan as Shivani's Daughter Sara Bareilles as Herself Julian Kenji Brescia as Guitar Student Jeff Taylor as Saint C's Artist