Guest Stars Lyndie Greenwood as Jennifer "Jenny" Mills John Noble as Henry Parrish Derek Mears as Moloch Clancy Brown as Sheriff August Corbin Laura Spencer as Reenactment Woman Victor Garber as Mr. Crane Co Starring Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Craig Branham as Headless Horseman Marti Matulis as Horseman of War Jahnee Wallace as Young Abbie Deja Dee as Desk Clerk Garrett Kruithof as Colonial Soldier India Scandrick as Teen Jenny John Curran as Oxford Professor Katie Malia as Faceless Woman Jeremy Tuttle as Latex Man #2 Jason Vail as Siamese Twin Demon #1