Guest Stars Sam Corlett as Caliban Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Skye P. Marshall as Mambo Michele Marie Le Fleur Luke Cook as Lucifer Morningstar / Dark Lord Caroline Rhea as Alternate Hilda Spellman Beth Broderick as Alternate Zelda Spellman Pollyanna McIntosh as Metatron Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Ty Wood as Billy Marlin Nelson Leis as Beelzebub Whitney Peak as Judith Blackwood Darius Willis as Judas Blackwood Jasmine Vega as Lizzie Connor Anthony as Milo Natalie Grace as Moth Seth Hastings as Student #1
