Guest Stars Mark Zeisler as Judge William Sullivan Enid Graham as Judge Wallace Callie Thorne as Madeline McBride Stacey Roca as Tracey Brennan Michael Park as Keith Watkins Brandy Burre as Dr. Soto Victor Slezak as Eric Godford Becca Nevins as Carla Cowley Co Starring Hannah Sullivan as Juror #22 / Foreperson Gabriel Lopez as Moving Man Boris Granolic as Jeremy Brennan