Guest Stars Katie Douglas as Abby Littman Chelsea Clark as Norah Daniel Beirne as Nick Mason Temple as Hunter Chen Sabrina Grdevich as Cynthia Fuller Alex Mallari Jr as PI Gabriel Cordova Humberly González as Sophie Sanchez Kelly McCormack as Maddie Kaden Boland-Trowbridge as Caleb Co Starring Nikki Roumel as Young Georgia Miller Kevin Hare as Principal Davies Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll as Anthony Sarah Abbott as Teenage Maddie Linda Carter as Office Secretary