Guest Stars Taylor Anthony Miller as Kelly Moran Vedette Lim as Elise Taylor Roshawn Franklin as Special Agent Trevor Hobbs Zach Appelman as Bob Avery Matt DeAngelis as Matt Grimes Flora Diaz as Lisa Avery Elisha Lawson as Yosef Alexander Chaplin as Neil Jacobs Christa Scott-Reed as Beth Travers Co Starring Mark David Watson as SWAT Leader Ryan William Martinez as NYPD Officer Alexis Molnar as Olivia Morgan McGhee as Birthday Girl Natasha Yvette Williams as Mrs. Adamu Hassiem Muhammad as James Adamu Josh Riley as Man Jenny Porrata as Maria Muñoz David Manuele as Josh Avery Juliana Himawan as Hannah