Guest Stars Cameron Monaghan as Jerome Valeska Mark Margolis as Paul Cicero Norm Lewis as Deputy Mayor Harrison Kane Co Starring J.W. Cortes as Detective Alvarez Krista Braun as Jennifer Luree Alex Corrado as Gabe Eric Elizaga as Reporter Gregory Konow as Detective Joshua Alscher as Young Man One Fidel Vicioso as Sergeant Charmaine Reedy as Venue Official Joey Elrose as Shadowy Figure Dante Melucci as Young Boy John Dewey as Young Man Two