Guest Stars Elizabeth Scopel as Sarah Fier Matthew Zuk as Mayor Will Goode Keil Oakley Zepernick as "Shame Killer" Isaac Milton Kevin Waterman as "The Milkman" Harry Rooker Emily Brobst as Billy Barker Michael Chandler as "The Pastor" Cyrus Miller Charlene Amoia as Rachel Thompson / Sunnyvale Customer Ted Sutherland as Young Nick Goode Todd Allen Durkin as Officer Kapinski Noah Garrett as Skull Mask Ryan Simpkins as Alice Lloyd Pitts as Nightwing Killer Meghan Packer as TV Anchor Lacy Camp as Mrs. Fraser Jeremy Ford as Peter Charlene Amoia as Beth Kimball Matthew Zuk as Elijah Goode Randall P. Havens as George Fier Todd Allen Durkin as The Watchman Nilah Blasingame as High School Kid Lynne Ashe as Union Townsman 3 Robert Bryan Davis as Union Townsman 2 Mark Ashworth as Jakob Berman Daniel Thomas May as Officer Kuzio Patrick Roper as Union Townsman 1 Lacy Camp as Grace Miller Jeremy Ford as Caleb Rachel Doman as Queen of Air and Darkness Girl
