Special Guest Stars Mary McDonnell as Helen Peterson Guest Stars Abigail Spencer as Misha Nelson Jalen Thomas Brooks as Sean Adam Arkin as Mark Duncan Daniella Garcia as Maddie Nina Millin as Judge Katerina Bobiak Matthew Glave as Tommy Flynn Eva Tamargo as Sharon Cruz Camille Chen as Naomi Lee Sarah Grace White as Jackie Emmett Preciado as Mateo Chloe Wepper as Carmen Co Starring Hunter Stiebel as Allan Bobby Neely as Taye Raquel Davies as Mallory Sundarri Rodriguez as Bianca B Z Cullins as Bailiff Lauren Letherer as Melanie Milcher Ian Nunney as Danny Irwin