Guest Stars Becca Tobin as Brooke Mailer Cristina Rosato as Olivia Doron Bell as Darius Lauren K. Robek as Connie Price Todd Thomson as Leigh Anderson Arghavan Jenati as Natalie Leaman Co Starring Caitlin Howden as Deputy Jenna Martin Jason Schombing as John Gillen Nancy Ebert as Clerk Katelyn Vanier as Aesthetician Keisha Haines as Amanda Mitchell Darryl B. King as Pedestrian #2 Marlee Walchuk as Pedestrian #1 Arman Nejadi as Bellman Denise McLaren as Mrs. Lafferty Andrea Scozzafava as Sharon from High School